This is Probably Right

by Dwayne Phillips

Mary had a little lamb, its fleece was white as snow.

And everywhere that Mary went, the lamb was sure to go. - Sarah Josepha Hale

“This is probably right,” said Fred.

“What?” said Dave. “What’d you say?”

“This is probably right,” repeated Fred. “These words are probably right.”

Dave sighed. Fred had broken his concentration. It was lost. Might as well see what Fred was doing. Fred would pester him until he did. Just do it.

Dave swiveled his chair and stood slowly. The blood rushed to his legs or some such things that gave him a little pain.

“Show me what you have,” said Dave.

“This,” said Fred. “Look at this. It’s probably right and that’s all it has to be, probably right, not definitely right.”

“You aren’t making any sense,” said Dave.

“Sure I am,” said Fred. “Look.”

Dave moved around to the other side of the cheap folding table that sat in the middle of the den where the two of them worked and ate and slept and lived. You might call it work. They had quit their jobs and started out on their own with great ideas and energy. At least they thought the ideas were great. After six months, no one else agreed.

“This,” said Fred, again. “This is it. This is probably right, and that is all it has to be, probably. Get it?”

Dave feigned understanding. He figured that would be the fastest way to get back to work and do something that amounted to something or some money. They needed some money. Fast.

“Mary had a little lamb,” said Fred as he swiveled his chair around and stood in excitement.

Fred jumped away from the cheap folding table and over to a roughly used and abused white board that was propped up in a rusty folding chair. He vainly tried to wipe the white board with the heel of his hand. That didn’t work, but it didn’t deter him. He grabbed a marker and tried to write on the white board. No ink. He tossed the marker across the den to the fireplace. He looked around but couldn’t find another marker.

“Here,” said Dave. “Try this one,” as he grabbed a marker from the cheap folding table and gave it to Fred.

Fred turned to the white board and wrote on top of its fading scribbles of three or four ideas that had not worked. He slowly and carefully wrote, “Mary had a little lamb.”

“There,” he said as if the words made an obvious connection to his excitement. “There you have it!”

Dave stood quietly for a moment. He motioned with both his hands in a rolling fashion as if to say, “Continue.”

“You see,” said Fred. “It’s the same old thing. Five words. Mary had a little lamb. There are at least five ways you can say this and another five ways you can ask it.”

“Okay,” said Fred. “Let me illustrate. MARY had a little lamb. The punch is on MARY. It’s not Sally or Sue or some other female name that starts with S, it’s Mary. That implies other people exist, but only MARY this time. It’s all about Mary.”

“That’s number 1,” said Fred. “Now, number 2: Mary HAD a little lamb. Past tense. She used to have a lamb. Now, she doesn’t. Someone stole her lamb from her or something else bad happened to the lamb like trying to cross the road or encountering a big bad wolf or something. Number 3: Mary had ‘A’ little lamb. A particular one. Just one, not many. And then…”

“I get it,” said Dave. “Stop, I get it. There are many ways people can interpret what they read. There are many ways people can interpret what they hear. Yep, yep, yep. That’s the way it goes.”

“And,” said Fred, “What determines how they interpret what they read? Huh? What about that?”

Dave answered with a shrug of his shoulders. He wanted to roll his eyes and get back to work, but Fred was rolling. Fred wouldn’t let him leave now.

“Expextations,” said Fred as if he had just solved the mystery of the universe with one pop of a word.

Fred continued his explanation, “People expect to read something, so whatever is put in front of them meets those expectations and they are satisfied. We don’t have to provide the right answer or the exact answer or anything like that. All we have to do is provide something that is probably right, something that is in the ballpark, and the reader will be satisfied. We will meet their expectations. They will think we are geniuses. They will buy our product no matter what we charge. This is the jackpot, the pot of gold we’ve been wanting. This is it!”

Dave paused. At least Fred had stopped talking and waving his arms. Perhaps now he could go back to work. But, no. The pause only allowed Fred to catch his breath, to think of the next thing to say, to continue his ranting.

Right on cue, Fred resumed talking, “So here, no, wait, uh, yeah, no, wait. Okay, here it is, this is it. Some guy, some user, is typing all sorts of things about property ownership and how women own property or don’t or something is out of proportion. Anyways, the keys are ownership and women. Our system spits out ‘Mary had a little lamb.’ The guy has great expectations about what he wants to say, we spit out a little nursery rhyme, something old with the copyright expired, the copyright part is important, and the guy reads some genius insight into the old nursery rhyme. Boom. Bam. Got it!”

Dave switched from being bored into thinking mode. This silly idea might not be so silly.

“How do we know what someone expects?” Dave asked.

“Hmm,” said Fred. “Good question.”

“How do we know what they were typing, what they were considering, their context?” Dave asked.

“Hmm,” said Fred. “Another good question.”

“Yes,” said Dave. “I can think of a few more of these good questions.”

“Exactly,” said Fred. “No, I mean probably. This is all probably. Nothing is exact. Nothing is definite. This is all probably right.”

“Okay,” said Dave. “We probably have some questions that probably need answers some time before our landlord probably kicks us out of this dump we live and work in.”

“Come on, Dave,” said Fred. “This one is going to work, probably. Just kidding. This one is definitely going to work. It can’t fail.”

Dave sighed. His shoulders dropped. Another goofy idea. Another moment of expectation, but nope, this one wouldn’t work either. Just another scheme that wouldn’t work.

Fred saw the reaction. It was familiar. Something told Fred to push harder.

“Give this one a minute or two, Dave,” said Fred. “Think about it. Walk around in circles or around the block or to the park or something. Whatever it is you do when you are really thinking. Think about this one. You can do it. You can work it out. You studied this stuff in grad school. Natural language, whatever stuff. You know this stuff.”

Dave stopped. The room was silent for a few moments. Dave knew that Fred hated those quiet moments. What surprised Dave was that Fred didn’t jump in with something to break the silence. What surprised Dave was that Fred was actually thinking quietly about this. Fred never thought quietly about anything. There might be something to this scheme. There probably is something to this scheme.

Dave turned, pushed his cheap swivel chair under the cheap folding table, and moved towards the door. “I’ll be back,” said Dave. “Going to walk around the block.”


Dave returned in half an hour. “This might work,” he said.

“Might?” said Fred. “Probably is the word. Probably is the word for this because our system will probably be right. And probably will be good enough.”

“I’ll stick with ‘might’,” said Dave. “This might work. There has been some research published lately that points to finding the intent in what someone has written. There is also some work in assigning possible meaning to phrases like old nursery rhymes. Match the probable intent with the probable phrase…”

“And bingo!” said Fred. “The answer comes out and it’s probably right. Right?”

“Actually,” said Dave, “Probable combined with probable is another probable that is less than the least of the first two. The probability of correctness drops with every combination. We could have a dozen combinations in every answer. That would not be greater than 0.5, so it would be improbable instead of probable.”

“You’re losing me, bud,” said Fred. “Anyways, I sense you have some ideas. I sense you can make a few ‘to do’ lists and start working them off and all those diligent things you do. You know, organized things and such.”

“Yeah,” Dave said. “Those organized things.”

Dave pulled a Field Notes notebook from his shirt pocket with its distinctive Kraft paper brown cover. He also grabbed a mechanical pencil, 0.5 mm lead of course, and clicked it a couple of times too many just for comfort.

“I made a few notes while walking,” said Dave. “A few more come to mind.”

The two paused while Dave scribbled.

“Who will pay for this?” asked Dave.

“Pay?” said Fred.

“Yes, pay,” said Dave. “Aside from a few trivial examples, we can’t run anything on these cheap, old computers we have. We’ll have to rent some cloud computing. Those guys expect money.”

“Money,” said Fred. “Yeah, money. Hey, don’t those guys usually give you the first 90 days or 30 days free or something like that? Maybe do one of those Wordpress-like things like we did a month ago. You know, some sort of around-the-back use of a computer that is free but not exactly using it as intended. Remember?”

“I remember, now,” said Dave. “That would hold us for a month. Will our landlord hold us for another month? I don’t want to sleep in your car and we had to sell my car last month to keep this up.”

“Sure,” said Fred. “My Grandma, uh, er, our landlord will let us slide for another month. We just have to keep her lawn mowed or rake her leaves and take out her trash. Christmas is coming around and she wants her lights hung. You know, things like that.”

Dave looked at the old computer on the cheap, old folding table. “This will only last a week on this type of problem. You make sure we have some other resources available this weekend. Right?”

“Sure,” said Fred.

“This weekend,” thought Dave. That was a silly notion. What was the difference between a weekday and a weekend? He had been working every day for, well, he couldn’t remember when they started this.

Dave sighed and said, “This might work. This might actually work.”

Fred’s eyes brightened. He had a good idea for once. He convinced Dave for once. This would probably work.

“What will we call this?” asked Dave.

“What do you mean?” asked Fred.

“We have to call it something,” said Dave. “At some point, someone is going to ask us what we call this. I mean, there is the idea, there is the algorithm, there is the system name. What are we going to call this?”

“The Mary system,” said Fred. “You know, M A R Y, we’ll think up some stuff for that acronym.

Dave’s expression killed that idea.

“I don’t know,” said Fred. “It’s still early.”

“We’ll need to write a white paper,” said Dave. “That is at the top of the list I wrote in the Field Notes.”

“Okay,” said Fred. “We’ll go with this.”

Dave braced himself for what came next. He didn’t brace himself well enough. He wondered if he would ever anticipate the crazy schemes Fred created.

“We’ll give all this some clever name,” said Fred. “You know, something different that catches their attention. Then we’ll write a paper that leaves out all the details. People will get excited, interpret our inadequate description of an algorithm, create something that approximates what we described. What they create will work. Their expectations will prove what they expected, that we had some brilliant idea.”

“You can’t be serious,” said Dave.

“Sure I am,” said Fred. “Others will do the work based on what they probably think we probably thought about how machines probably think. It’s foolproof.”

Dave could think of nothing to say. He had a list of things to work. Perhaps now, Fred would leave him alone. Fred would run off and start calling people on the phone and conning them into lending us resources for 30 days free or something like that. Fred would talk to his grandmother. Dave couldn’t imagine how Fred’s grandmother would yield to his requests. Surely some of Fred’s cousins would rightly convince their grandmother to stop listening to Fred. Never mind. Those were other problems for other people.

“The key is, we don’t have to be right,” Fred said. “People will believe whatever we spit out. They will read the correct intent regardless. This is easy. All we have to be is probably right.”

“Nope,” said Dave. “Won’t work. People aren’t that gullible. People are too smart.”

“Are you sure people are smart?” said Fred. “Look at me.”


Author’s Note: I made up this story. It is a silly story. It is not connected to any actual events or people. I don’t know any of the people who created these text-generating systems. I am sure they are smart, hard-working people. I mean no disrespect.

The End